Research ArticleEVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY

Blue reflectance in tarantulas is evolutionarily conserved despite nanostructural diversity

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science Advances  27 Nov 2015:
Vol. 1, no. 10, e1500709
DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.1500709
  • Fig. 1 Ancestral character analysis for blue coloration.

    Blue color evolved at least eight times (▲) and was lost at least five times (▲) during evolution of Theraphosidae. The basal origin of blue is likely an artifact to the highly conservative assignment of blue as the ancestral state for any genus containing a blue species. (A to I) Photos representing the appearance of nine blue tarantula species are shown above the phylogeny. Photos courtesy of T. Patterson.

  • Fig. 2 Color, morphology, and nanostructure of blue hairs.

    Colors observed under a microspectrophotometer [light microscopy (LM)]. Center black square (spectra-measured area), 4 × 4 μm. (A to H) Three types of hair morphology were observed under SEM: (i) smooth cylindrical hairs (A and H), (ii) irregular/bladelike protruding hairs (B, C, E, and F), and (iii) symmetric lobe-like protruding hairs (D and G). Two types of nanostructures were observed under TEM: (i) multilayer structure (D to G) and (ii) quasi-ordered structure (A to C). High-reflectance ridges are observed in (D). The center portion of the hair in (H) is blue, but not on the periphery. This is probably caused solely by the optical effect of a hollow, semitransparent fiber (that is, the hair). No conspicuous nanostructure was observed in (H). Scale bar, 2 μm. (A) Euathlus pulcherrimaklaasi. (B) Tapinauchenius violaceus. (C) Chromatopelma cyaneopubescens. (D) Lampropelma violaceopes. (E) Ephebopus cyanognathus (TEM photo courtesy of R. F. Foelix). (F) Avicularia laeta. (G) Poecilotheria metallica. (H) Grammostola rosea.

  • Fig. 3 Coherent scattering analyses by Fourier Analysis Tool for Biological Nano-optics.

    Column I: Selected TEM micrographs that represent observed nanostructures. (A to H) Quasi-ordered structure (A to C) and multilayer structure (D to G). No structure is seen in (H). Scale bar, 250 nm. Column II: Two-dimensional (2D) Fourier power spectra of column I. Column III: Predicted reflectance spectra based on column II. (A) E. pulcherrimaklaasi. (B) T. violaceus. (C) C. cyaneopubescens. (D) L. violaceopes. (E) E. cyanognathus (photo courtesy of R. F. Foelix). (F) A. laeta. (G) P. metallica. (H) G. rosea.

  • Fig. 4 Reflectance spectra of tarantulas and Polyommatus butterflies.

    (A) Normalized reflectance spectral measurements of tarantulas (solid lines) show conservation of peak reflectance around 450 nm. Theoretical spectra are calculated from multilayer simulations (dashed lines) and matched the measured spectra fairly well. (B) Normalized reflectance spectral measurements of Polyommatus butterflies (19) show peak reflectance broadly distributed across 400 to 500 nm. The gray area indicates the interquartile range.

  • Fig. 5 Distribution of blue colorations in Theraphosidae, Lepidoptera, and Aves.

    (A) Scatterplots (means ± SD) of reflectance peak positions for blue Theraphosidae, Lepidoptera, and Aves. Reflectance peak distribution in Theraphosidae has a trend to be narrower than that in Lepidoptera and Aves. The c.v. is 4.65% for Theraphosidae, 8.94% for Lepidoptera, and 6.13% for Aves. (B) Scatterplot for the data points in (A) and their differences to the mean value of each group. The smaller the value, the closer it resides to the mean. However, only Lepidoptera, not Aves, show a significant difference from Theraphosidae (P = 0.039), designated by the asterisk sign, potentially because of the outlier in Theraphosidae and the small sample size. Data for the Theraphosidae group are from our own observations, whereas those shown for the Lepidoptera and Aves groups are from data available from the literature. The Lepidoptera group is composed of nine species of Polyommatus butterflies from Fig. 4 and nine other species from table S1. The Aves group is composed of 10 species from table S1, including birds from three different orders: (i) parrot (Psittaciformes), (ii) penguin (Sphenisciformes), and (iii) songbird (Passeriformes).

  • Table 1 Results summary.

    FFT, fast Fourier transform; ml, multilayer; n.a., not applicable.

    SpeciesConditionColor,
    region
    Observed peak
    (nm)
    Predicted peak
    (nm)
    Hair
    nanostructure
    Thickness/
    distance (nm)
    Native location
    E. pulcherrimaklaasiSubadult,
    dissecting
    Purple, leg406.5390 (FFT)Quasi-ordered120.4*Ecuador, ground habitat
    T. violaceusSubadult,
    dissecting
    Purple, leg462470 (FFT)Quasi-ordered159.9*French Guiana, Brazil,
    arboreal
    C. cyaneopubescensSubadult,
    exuvia
    Blue, leg478460 (FFT)Quasi-ordered141.1*Venezuela, Paraguana,
    ground habitat
    L. violaceopesAdult,
    dissecting
    Blue, leg450440 (FFT)
    424 (ml)
    MultilayerChitin: 92 ± 5
    Air: 55 ± 6
    Malaysia, Singapore,
    arboreal
    E. cyanognathusSpiderling,
    exuvia
    Blue,
    chelicerae
    458440 (FFT)
    388 (ml)
    MultilayerChitin: 76 ± 13
    Air: 69 ± 12
    French Guiana,
    ground habitat
    A. laetaSpiderling,
    exuvia
    Blue, leg447.5420 (FFT)
    444 (ml)
    MultilayerChitin: 86 ± 7
    Air: 81 ± 8
    Brazil, Puerto Rico,
    arboreal
    P. metallicaSubadult,
    exuvia
    Purple, leg440480 (FFT)
    432 (ml)
    MultilayerChitin: 83 ± 5
    Air: 80 ± 5
    India, arboreal
    G. roseaAdult,
    dissecting
    Pink,
    carapace
    459n.a.n.a.n.a.Chile, Bolivia, Argentina,
    ground habitat

    *Calculated from predicted peak [½ × predicted peak (nm)/averaged refractive index].

    †Based on Fig. 2E [TEM photo courtesy of R. F. Foelix (18)].

    Supplementary Materials

    • Supplementary material for this article is available at http://advances.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/1/10/e1500709/DC1

      Fig. S1. Blue tarantula exemplars.

      Fig. S2. Color survey and phylogenetic tree of 53 tarantula genera.

      Fig. S3. Refractive index test.

      Fig. S4. The blue color in tarantulas has a large viewing angle.

      Table S1. The distribution of blue coloration in Lepidoptera and Aves.

      References (5462)

    • Supplementary Materials

      This PDF file includes:

      • Fig. S1. Blue tarantula exemplars.
      • Fig. S2. Color survey and phylogenetic tree of 53 tarantula genera.
      • Fig. S3. Refractive index test.
      • Fig. S4. The blue color in tarantulas has a large viewing angle.
      • Table S1. The distribution of blue coloration in Lepidoptera and Aves.
      • References (54–62)

      Download PDF

      Files in this Data Supplement: