Protecting hot carriers by tuning hybrid perovskite structures with alkali cations

See allHide authors and affiliations

Science Advances  23 Oct 2020:
Vol. 6, no. 43, eabb1336
DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.abb1336


Successful implementation of hot carrier solar cells requires preserving high carrier temperature as carriers migrate through the active layer. Here, we demonstrated that addition of alkali cations in hybrid organic-inorganic lead halide perovskites led to substantially elevated carrier temperature, reduced threshold for phonon bottleneck, and enhanced hot carrier transport. The synergetic effects from the Rb, Cs, and K cations result in ~900 K increase in the effective carrier temperature at a carrier density around 1018 cm−3 with an excitation 1.45 eV above the bandgap. In the doped thin films, the protected hot carriers migrate 100 s of nanometers longer than the undoped sample as imaged by ultrafast microscopy. We attributed these improvements to the relaxation of lattice strain and passivation of halide vacancies by alkali cations based on x-ray structural characterizations and first principles calculations.


The theoretical maximum power conversion efficiency (PCE) of a hot carrier solar cell can be as high as 66% (1), substantially above the Shockley-Queisser limit (2). However, the efforts to apply the hot carrier strategy in practice have so far been hindered by hot carrier cooling that is usually much faster than the time needed to transport the charge carriers in conventional semiconductors (3). Hybrid organic-inorganic metal halide perovskite semiconductors have emerged as an exciting class of materials for high-performance solar cells with PCE over 24% (46). Recent studies revealed unusually slow picosecond carrier cooling coupled with long-range hot carrier transport, suggesting large potential of hot carrier solar cells based on hybrid perovskites (7, 8). At high carrier densities, the hot phonon bottleneck, further extends carrier cooling time scale up to hundreds of picoseconds (913). Hot carrier cooling and transport in hybrid perovskites have been shown to differ from traditional semiconductors substantially due to the interplay between large polaron formation and a dynamic ionic lattice (7, 14, 15).

Despite the impressive progress, challenges remain in achieving high carrier temperature at reasonable carrier density while maintaining thermal stability. Taking advantage of the programmable and flexible structure of hybrid perovskites, a possible route to address these challenges is through fine-tuning of the structure to influence phonon and defect scattering processes (16, 17) and achieve better stability. The general structure for hybrid perovskites is ABX3; the B site is a divalent metallic atom (typically Pb2+ or Sn2+), the X site is a halide (Cl, Br, and I), and the A site is an intercalating cation. The A site cation can be either organic, such as CH3NH3+ (methylammonium, MA+) and CH(NH2)2+ (formamidinium, FA+), or inorganic, for instance, Cs+. Success has been achieved recently with the incorporation of a small amount of alkali metals (such as Rb+ and K+), demonstrating stabilized perovskite structures at high temperatures and suppression of ion migration (6, 18, 19). The addition of alkali cations has also been shown to reduce the recombination of cooled carriers at the band edge by passivating defects (2023); however, the influence of the alkali cations on the dynamics of hot carriers above the band edge is unknown.

Here, we showed that the incorporation of alkali cations can markedly modify hot carrier relaxation and transport by using ultrafast transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy and microscopy combined with first principles calculations. The synergetic effects from the Rb, Cs, and K cations lead to properties beneficial for hot carrier solar cells, including elevated carrier temperature over tens of picosecond time scale and enhanced hot carrier transport over hundreds of nanometer length scale. By suppressing the loss of excessive energy to defects, the alkali cations also reduce the threshold carrier density for achieving picosecond carrier cooling via hot phonon effect by an order of magnitude. These results underscore the opportunities in designing optimal hybrid perovskite structures for hot carrier solar cells.


Sample characterizations

To explore composition tuning to influence hot carrier cooling and transport, we used (MAPbBr3)0.17(FAPbI3)0.83 that was commonly used in high-performance solar cells as the reference sample and that is referred to as “MAFA” throughout the article (6). Five different cation combinations were investigated in this work. Three triple cation perovskites were made by adding either 5% of cesium iodide (CsI), or 5% of rubidium iodide (RbI), or 5% of potassium iodide (KI) to the MAFA reference, named “CsMAFA,” “RbMAFA,” and “KMAFA,” respectively. The percentage corresponds to the molar concentration of the alkali cations in the perovskite precursor solution. The quadruple cation perovskite material containing both 5% of Cs and 5% of Rb is referred to as RbCsMAFA. Last, a quintuple cation composition with 5% Cs, 5% Rb, and 5% K is called RbCsKMAFA. Polycrystalline thin films with thickness of 400 to 450 nm were deposited on 0.17-mm-thick glass coverslips (a scanning electron microscopy image is shown in fig. S1A).

We performed x-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements to investigate the structural changes induced by the addition of the alkali cations (Fig. 1A). The FAPbI3 perovskite δ phase, detrimental for optoelectronic applications, is present for the RbMAFA and RbCsMAFA samples and has been reported for the MAFA samples previously (24), as evident from the peaks around 12°. The δ phase is suppressed when adding K+, as shown for RbCsKMAFA and KMAFA. However, it is possible that the δ phase is present for some of these compounds without showing a peak because not all orientations are detectable by thin-film XRD. In addition, the PbI2 (001) peak disappears when mixed alkali metals are present, as evidenced by the decrease in the peak around 12.7°. We calculated the lattice constants from the perovskite peak at around 14° and observed an increase when adding alkali metals with the largest increase for RbCsKMAFA (Fig. 1B). While the incorporation of Rb or K in the structure is still under debate, the expanded lattices suggest the incorporation of the alkali metals at the A site, the large X site halide, or both (25). To accommodate the cations while maintaining an overall cubic symmetry, the positions of I and Br across the lattices could also be modified. Full width at half maximum (FWHM) from the perovskite peak at around 14° is the smallest for the RbCsKMAFA perovskite, which can be explained by increased crystallite size. All the compositions investigated display similar bandgaps at around 1.6 eV, as shown in the steady-state photoluminescence (PL) spectra (Fig. 1D) and absorption spectra (fig. S1B), with small shifts in energy consistent with a previous report (25).

Fig. 1 Structural and optoelectronic properties modulated by alkali cations.

(A) XRD patterns, (B) the lattice constants, and (C) the FWHM of the perovskite peak. The lattice constants and FWHM were extracted from the peak at around 14°. a.u., arbitrary unit. (D) Steady-state PL spectra. (E) Time-resolved PL decay curves for samples with different cation combinations. Elongation of PL lifetime is observed with the addition of alkali cations.

We also used x-ray fluorescence (XRF) microscopy to map the distribution of the different inorganic components of the perovskite films. The elemental distribution for the Br-to-Pb ratio, Rb, and K maps are illustrated in fig. S1C. Rb+ and Cs+ homogenize the bromine aggregates compared with the MAFA samples, which is beneficial for solar cell performance and stability (6). However, the presence of Rb+ also leads to needle-like Rb agglomerates. The addition of K to RbCsMAFA leads to halide homogenization and lower concentration of Rb clusters. Time-resolved PL measurements were carried out to investigate how the interband recombination of cooled carriers is affected by the alkali cations (Fig. 1E). Overall, the addition of Rb+, Cs+, and K+ increases the PL lifetime, with the longest PL lifetime observed in KMAFA, consistent with previous reports (6, 21, 23, 25). Furthermore, the recombination on the short time scale (fig. S1D) is suppressed most notably when all three cations are incorporated in RbCsK.

Carrier cooling modulated by alkali cations

Hot carrier cooling dynamics in different multication perovskite thin films was characterized using TA spectroscopy with identical experimental conditions for the measurements on different samples. Carrier cooling can be substantially modified by incorporating a small amount of alkali cations. Figure 2 (A and B) shows the time-dependent TA spectra of MAFA and RbCsMAFA with a pump photon energy of 3.10 eV, respectively. Upon photoexcitation, a ground-state bleach band (GSB, positive signal in ΔT/T, where ΔT is pump-induced change in probe transmission and T is the probe transmission) centered around the bandgap at 1.64 eV is observed due to the band-filling effect. As schematically illustrated in fig. S2A, carrier-carrier scattering events rapidly distribute initial nonequilibrium carriers into a Fermi-Dirac distribution, which can be described by an effective temperature. Carrier thermalization occurs on a time scale of 85 fs (26), which is beyond our time resolution of ~200 fs. The broad high-energy bleach tails observed in Fig. 2 (A and B) represent the Fermi-Dirac distribution, and they gradually narrow as the carriers cool down. A photoinduced absorption (negative signal in ΔT/T) band near 1.58 eV is also observed at delay time shorter than 1 ps, which has been assigned to bandgap renormalization due to hot carriers (8, 9). At a very short time scale, the trade-off from bandgap renormalization (red shift) and Burstein-Moss effect (blue shift) causes a slightly red-shifted GSB peak.

Fig. 2 Hot carrier cooling modulated by alkali cations.

(A and B) Normalized TA spectra of pump at 3.10 eV with excitation density of 1.3 × 1018 cm−3 at different pump-probe delays for MAFA (A) and RbCsKMAFA (B), respectively. Spectral broadening at early delay time indicates hot carrier distributions. The black dashed lines are fits to the high-energy bleach tail with the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution to extract effective carrier temperature Tc, as described in the main text. (C and D) Extracted Tc of MAFA and RbCsKMAFA as a function of delay time at different carrier densities. (E) Carrier cooling curves for different samples at N0 of 1.3 × 1018 cm−3, displaying strong dependence on alkali cations. (F) Similar initial Tc and cooling behavior can be achieved in RbCsKMAFA with an order of magnitude lower N0 than the reference MAFA (3 × 1017 versus 3 × 1018 cm−3). Solid lines are the fitted with biexponential or triexponential functions, and the fitting parameters are given in table S1.

The incorporation of alkali cations leads to broader higher-energy tails at 200 fs (fig. S2B). We extracted the effective carrier temperature Tc to describe the quasi-equilibrium distribution of the hot carriers. Tc is obtained by fitting the high-energy bleach tail above the bandgap with the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution (10)ΔTT(ω)=A0(ω)exp(ωkBTc)(1)where ℏω is the probe energy, A0 is the linear absorbance, and kB is the Boltzmann constant. To ensure the carrier distributions can be defined by an effective temperature, we extracted Tc after carrier thermalization (26) at a time delay of 200 fs or longer. Fig. 2 (C and D) shows the fitting results at different injected carrier density N0 for MAFA and RbCsKMAFA, respectively. To account for the slight variation in the bandgap energy of different compositions, we fitted the data from different samples at 0.05 eV above their respective bleach maximum at 850 ps (after carrier cooling has concluded). Shifting the fitting window slightly (~0.03 eV) does not change Tc substantially as shown in fig. S2C. Carrier cooling curves from different samples at N0 of 1.3 × 1018 cm−3 are compared in Fig. 2E.

Carrier temperature can be increased by the incorporation of alkali cations. Adding Cs+ increases the initial carrier temperature slightly to ~700 K in comparison with that of ~640 K for MAFA with overall similar cooling behaviors. Carrier temperature is enhanced more notably by the addition of Rb+ and K+, increasing initial Tc to ~800 and ~ 950 K, respectively. Carrier temperature is further elevated when multiple alkali cations are incorporated. When both Rb+ and Cs+ are incorporated, RbCsMAFA exhibits higher initial Tc compared with both RbMAFA and CsMAFA. The highest Tc is achieved when all three alkali cations are incorporated in RbCsKMAFA, ~1500 K at N0 of 1.3 × 1018 cm−3, and ~5000 K at N0 of 3.0 × 1018 cm−3 at 200 fs. There could be fitting errors due to the convolution of the GSB peak with the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution given by Eq. 1 (27). However, the variations in the peak width do not explain the trend observed in Fig. 2E, as RbCsKMAFA (the highest Tc) and MAFA (the lowest Tc) have similar FWHM for GSB peak as shown in fig. S2D. In contrast, CsMAFA has the largest FWHM but the second lowest Tc. We also quantified the effect of peak width in the temperature fitting by comparing Tc from Eq. 1 with Tc obtained from the fitting to the convolution of Eq. 1 with a Gaussian peak shape as described in (27) (more details in note S1A). These two methods yield the same trend as a function of alkali cations and similar Tc values with a deviation <5% (fig. S3), indicating the broadening from the GSB peak width does not substantially affect the extracted Tc. Furthermore, we have extracted Tc by fitting the whole TA spectra using the model described in (10, 28) that considers Fermi-Dirac distribution of the carriers, broadening of the exciton and free carrier transitions, and bandgap renormalization effects (fig. S4 and note S1B). The temperatures extracted from these fits are within 14% of the fits from the Maxwell-Boltzmann method with the same trend as a function of alkali cations. Therefore, all three fitting models yield overall similar results, which confirms that the approximation to a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution is valid for our experimental conditions.

Carrier cooling can be roughly divided into two regimes, with a fast subpicosecond cooling and slow cooling ranging from picoseconds to hundreds of picoseconds (7, 911, 13, 26). For the subpicosecond time scale, before the formation of polarons, the cooling of the hot bare carriers is dominated by the emission of the optical phonon via the Fröhlich mechanism. Fitting of carrier cooling in the subpicosecond regime returned fast decay constants of 200 to 300 fs for all samples. Additional slower cooling stages are observed with decay time up to hundreds of picoseconds at sufficiently high carrier densities (Fig. 2, C and D, and fig. S5), which is attributed to the hot phonon bottleneck effect (913, 29). The bottleneck occurs when the emission of optical phonons (12, 30) builds up a nonequilibrium phonon population that can transfer energy back to the electron system. The addition of K+ and Rb+ lowers the carrier density threshold for the phonon bottleneck, leading to slow picosecond cooling at density as low as 3 × 1017 cm−3 (the slow cooling is absent from MAFA and CsMAFA at this carrier density as illustrated in fig. S5). Similar initial Tc and cooling behavior can be achieved in RbCsKMAFA with an order of magnitude lower N0 compared with the reference MAFA as shown in Fig. 2F (3 × 1017 cm−3 versus 3 × 1018 cm−3). When the initial carrier temperature is ~1000 K or above and most notably with the incorporation of K+, a third exponential term with time constant of 3 to 7 ps is necessary to describe the cooling, possibly due to an additional relaxation pathway for the optical phonons (Fig. 2E). This additional decay leads to a higher Tc in RbCsMAFA than in RbCsKMAFA at delays >10 ps. The fitting parameters for the cooling curves shown in Fig. 2 and fig. S5 are given in table S1. Auger heating has also been proposed to contribute to the slow carrier cooling (13). However, Auger recombination would also lead to additional loss of carrier population. As shown in fig. S6, carrier dynamics is independent of carrier density for N0 ranging from 3 × 1017 to 3 × 1018 cm−3, suggesting negligible Auger annihilation. Therefore, we conclude that phonon bottleneck is the dominant mechanism for the slow carrier cooling observed here.

The large difference in the initial Tc and subsequent cooling processes between different samples indicates that energy loss (inelastic) carrier scattering events within 200 fs are altered by the addition of the alkali cations. These processes could include carrier defect or carrier impurity scattering that occurs on the time scales of 200 fs or shorter (31). The alkali cations also reduce the threshold carrier density for hot phonon effects, because the loss of excessive energy to defects is suppressed. Cs+ can replace the MA+ or FA+ in the perovskite structure and can be found homogeneously within the material (32), but the smaller Rb+ and K+ do not substitute the organic cations. Cs+ leads to the least increase in Tc, suggesting that the suppressed scattering is likely not due to replacing MA or FA. Overall, highest Tc is achieved in RbCsKMAFA, implying synergetic effects from the three cations. At a time scale of 200 fs or shorter, structural changes at the localized nanometer length scale are expected to play a more important role than the hundreds of nanometer to micrometer morphology variations. From the XRD results, RbCsKMAFA and RbCsMAFA exhibit the most expansion of the lattice and the sharpest (100) diffraction peaks (Fig. 1, B and C), which are the signatures of relaxed local strain, as previously shown in hybrid perovskite structures after light soaking (33). Lattice strains can lead to energy fluctuations or structural defects locally on the nanometer scale, which could serve as additional scattering centers for hot carriers. For example, local lattice strains have been shown to lead to additional hot carrier scattering pathways that accelerate carrier cooling in semiconducting quantum wells (34). Thus, it is possible that relaxation of local strain by the alkali cations reduces hot carrier scattering and leads to increased Tc.

The addition of the alkali cations has also been suggested to passivate other structural defects such as halide vacancies (2023). The role of defects in quenching hot carrier temperature has been implied previously by the cooler carriers at grain boundaries with presumably higher defect density as revealed by spatially resolved TA measurements (35). The fact that KMAFA displays a substantially higher Tc than RbMAFA and CsMAFA is consistent with that K+ was proposed to be more effective in passivating halide vacancies (20). Compensating the halide vacancies could also lead to the shifting of the Fermi level toward the middle of the bandgap (20) and reduce the overall carrier density and carrier-carrier scattering, leading to higher Tc. In addition, we observed that the PL lifetime at the short time scale (fig. S1D) correlates with initial Tc shown in Fig. 2E (both in the order of RbCsK > K ~ RbCs > Rb > CS ~ MAFA). This agreement indicates that the defects that lead to the PL recombination at the subnanosecond time scale are the more localized ones that also quench hot carrier temperatures. Note that the Rb agglomerates with sizes >100 nm could lead to recombination on a time scale longer than 10 ns; however, they do not result in substantially detrimental effects in hot carrier scattering at the hundreds of femtosecond time scale, and an improved carrier temperature is observed in RbMAFA compared with MAFA.

Ab initio calculations of hot carrier scattering by halide vacancies

We use ab initio nonadiabatic (NA) molecular dynamics (MD) (36, 37) simulations to gain further insights into how the localized defects affect the hot carrier cooling process (more details in note S2). Because vacancies can break the continuity of chemical bonding by virtue of both missing atom and missing interatomic linkages, they are expected to be efficient scattering sites. Thus far, the investigation of halide vacancies has been focused exclusively on their effect on the recombination of cooled carriers at the band edge due to defect states within the bandgap (20, 21, 23). Here, we simulated the intraband relaxation of hot carriers in pristine MAPbI3 and compared it to that in the presence of an iodine vacancy (Iv). The simulation details are given in note S1, and the results are presented in Fig. 3. The density of states (DOS) at 300 K shown in Fig. 3 (A and B) demonstrates that Iv introduces a midgap state, which can lead to additional recombination channels for the cooled carriers and shorter PL lifetimes. Iv also increases the DOS near the conduction band minimum (CBM), as highlighted in Fig. 3B by the blue oval. The increased DOS near the CBM can influence intraband relaxation, which is relevant for hot carrier cooling. The higher DOS contributes carrier scattering pathways, which can lead to a lower initial carrier temperature and faster cooling (Fig. 3C).

Fig. 3 Ab initio calculations on the effect of Ivs on carrier cooling.

(A and B) Atom-projected DOS for pristine MAPbI3 (A) and lattice with Iv (B) for representative structures at 300 K. The zero of energy is at the Fermi level. The insets show atomic structures, with the red circle indicating the defect location. The Iv introduces a strong peak in the DOS near the CBM, highlighted with the blue oval. The increased DOS accelerates hot electron cooling. (C) Hot electron relaxation. The relaxation is accelerated by Iv due to the increased DOS near the CBM.

In addition to the higher DOS, the states near the vacancies are more localized (fig. S7). Typically, electron-phonon coupling is stronger for localized electronic states. For instance, excitation of localized molecular states can lead to large Stokes shifts and bond breaking, while excitation of delocalized states in bulk materials has little influence on their geometries and phonon frequencies. The localization of the electronic states in the presence of Iv increases the NA electron-phonon coupling and accelerates electron-phonon relaxation and hot carrier cooling. Overall, the NA MD calculation presents a feasible explanation for how the addition of alkali cations modify intraband relaxation and hot carrier dynamics by passivating the halide vacancies.

Enhancing hot carrier transport by alkali cations

Long-range transport is also necessary for the success of hot carrier solar cells in addition to the need of preserving carrier temperature. Here, we used TA microscopy (TAM) to directly image the transport of the hot carrier population protected by alkali metal cations. To image carrier transport, we held the pump beam at a fixed position, while the probe beam is scanned relative to the pump with a Galvanometer scanner, and ∆T is plotted as a function of probe position to form an image (fig. S8; more details in Materials and Methods and note S3) (38). The probe is at 1.65 eV resonant with the bandgap. The initial population is created by a Gaussian pump beam at position (x0, y0) with a pulse duration of ~300 fs, n(x,y,0)=Nexp[(xx0)22σ0,x2(yy0)22σ0,y2]. The time-dependent TAM images reflect carrier diffusion away from the initial excitation volume. The resulting two-dimensional (2D) TAM images are shown in Fig. 4A for a pump photon energy of 3.10 eV at N0 = 5.0 × 1017 cm−3 for the RbCsKMAFA thin film (and the images for MAFA and RbCsMAFA are shown in fig. S9, A and B, respectively). The TAM profiles shown in Fig. 4A are fitted by 2D Gaussian functions with variances of σt,x2 and σt,y2, where σt,x2 and σt,y2 are the time-dependent variances of the Gaussian profiles along the x and y axes. At delay time t, the carrier population is given by n(x,y,t)=Nexp[(xx0)22σt,x2(yy0)22σt,x2]. The Gaussian fits along one direction are shown in Fig. 4B (the Gaussian profiles for MAFA and RbCsMAFA are shown in fig. S9, A and B, respectively). Because the carrier transport is isotropic, σt,x2=σt,y2=σt2 (8). σt2σ02 represents the average distance traveled by the carriers during delay time t. For the transport measurements, the critical resolution of TAM of ~50 nm comes from the uncertainty of σt and σ0, which is limited by the signal-to-noise rather than the diffraction limit (more details in note S3) (38).

Fig. 4 Enhancing hot carrier transport by alkali cations.

(A) The TAM images of the carrier transport in RbCsKMAFA at various delay times. Probe energy = 1.65 eV, pump energy = 3.10 eV, and N0 = 5.0 × 1017 cm−3. The color scale represents the intensity of pump-induced differential transmission (ΔT) of the probe, and every image has been normalized by peak value. Scale bar, 500 nm. (B) Cross sections of the TAM images shown in (A) fitted with Gaussian functions, with the maximum ∆T signal normalized. (C) σt2 plotted as a function of pump-probe delay time, comparing hot carrier transport in MAFA, RbCsMAFA, and RbCsKMAFA. Probe energy = 1.65 eV. The dashed lines are guide to the eye. More rapid hot carrier transport is observed in RbCsMAFA and RbCsKMAFA than in MAFA. The error bars of σt2 indicate the uncertainties of the Gaussian fitting. (D) Transport of cooled carriers; σt2 at time delay >500 ps for MAFA, RbCsMAFA, and RbCsKMAFA at N0 = 5.0 × 1017 cm−3. (E and F) Longer-range hot carrier transport is observed at higher carrier density for RbCsKMAFA (E) and RbCsMAFA (F). σt2 plotted as a function of pump-probe delay time under different excitation densities.

The TAM results show a two-step transport behavior: enhanced transport of the hot carriers during early delay time and normal diffusion of the cooled carriers at later time (Fig. 4). Enhanced hot carrier transport was observed to correlate with higher carrier temperature induced by alkali cation incorporation, beneficial for hot solar cell applications. We compared hot carrier transport at a N0 of 5.0 × 1017 cm−3 in the two compositions that are most promising for hot carrier solar cell applications, RbCsMAFA and RbCsKMAFA, to that in MAFA (Fig. 4C). At early delay time, the transport of the carriers in both RbCsKMAFA and RbCsMAFA with higher Tc is more rapid than the carriers in MAFA (Fig. 4C). Hot carriers migrated the largest distance in RbCsKMAFA, ~230 nm greater than MAFA and ~200 nm greater than RbCsMAFA (by subtracting the difference in σ150 ps2 in Fig. 4C). Note that hot carrier transport on the subpicosecond time scales in hybrid perovskites is dominated by quasi-ballistic transport of hot bare band carriers, and carrier propagation has occurred within the pulse duration of ~300 fs, leading to a σ02 value larger than the convolution of the pump and probe beams (8, 39). The highest initial Tc in RbCsKMAFA results in the longest-range quasi-ballistic carrier migration within the pulse duration, as demonstrated by the largest σ02 value (Fig. 4C). The diffusion constant of the thermally equilibrated cooled carriers at time scale >500 ps is lower in RbCsKMAFA than in MAFA (0.02 cm2 s−1 versus 0.18 cm2 s−1) as shown in Fig. 4D. Therefore, we can exclude better mobility in RbCsKMAFA as the reason for the enhanced transport of the hot carriers.

The enhanced hot carrier transport is consistent with the higher Tc in RbCsKMAFA and RbCsMAFA than in MAFA as shown in Fig. 2E and can be explained by that a higher Tc leads to a larger velocity of the carriers as given by v=3kBTcm*, where m* is the effective mass. Under the same carrier density, hot carriers propagate shorter distance in RbCsMAFA than in RbCsKMAFA because of lower carrier temperature in RbCsMAFA (Fig. 2D and fig. S5D). Hot carrier transport can be further enhanced by increasing carrier density. Faster transport is observed for RbCsKMAFA and RbCsMAFA at higher carrier density (shown in Fig. 4, E and F, respectively), again consistent with higher carrier temperature at a large N0 due to hot phonon effect (Fig. 2D and fig. S5D). Because the density is higher at the center of the spot than at the edge of the Gaussian pump beam, leading to faster decay due to Auger annihilation, annihilation could lead to artificial broadening of σ at higher carrier density. We rule out the influence of Auger annihilation here based on the negligible carrier density–dependent recombination as shown in fig. S6. The variation of the carrier density within the Gaussian pump beam could also lead to spatially dependent carrier cooling. To fully address this spatial dependence, a detailed Monte Carlo simulation that takes into account both the cooling and transport processes is necessary, which is beyond the scope of this work. Instead, here, we interpret the TAM results as the averaged transport behaviors of all the excited carriers.

The enhanced transport persists for longer time in RbCsMAFA than in RbCsKMAFA (~300 versus ~150 ps; Fig. 4, E and F), consistent with a slower carrier cooling process in RbCsMAFA (Fig. 2E). The two-step transport transition time point correlates with the cooling time of 220 and 150 ps for RbCsMAFA and RbCsKMAFA at an excitation density of 1.3 × 1018 cm−3, respectively (table S1). This correlation of the duration of enhanced transport with the carrier cooling time provides additional support for hot carrier diffusion. While small spatial variations in the diffusion constants are observed, similar time-dependent transport behaviors are reproducible among different sample locations (fig. S10). The SD for σt2σ02 from multiple datasets is ±6 and ±9% for RbCsMAFA and RbCsKMAFA, respectively.


The results presented here highlight the unique advantage of solution-processable hybrid perovskites with programmable structures over other candidates for hot carrier solar cells such as semiconducting quantum wells that require epitaxial growth (40). By simple solution chemistry of adding a small amount of alkali metal halides in the precursors, significant improvement on hot carrier temperature and migration can be achieved. The carrier density required for achieving slow picosecond carrier cooling by hot phonon effect is also reduced by the alkali cations. X-ray structural characterizations and theory simulations suggest that these improvements result from the combined effects of the relaxation of local strains and the passivation of defects. RbCsKMAFA is the most promising structure with overall highest carrier temperature and longest-range transport obtained, implying the synergetic effects from the Rb+, Cs+, and K+ cations. The protected hot carriers in alkali cation–incorporated structures that have demonstrated superior thermal stability (6) suggest that these structures are practical for hot carrier applications. At a carrier density of ~1018 cm−3 (~100 sun, can be achieved using solar concentrator), carrier temperature greater than 600 K can be maintained over a time scale of >10 ps and a distance over hundreds of nanometers, which has the potential for achieving a PCE >45% in a hot carrier solar cell (1).


Sample preparation and structural characterization

The preparation and structural characterizations (XRD and XRF mapping) of the perovskite thin films are based on methods described previously (6). The alkali metal iodides were added as CsI, RbI, and KI in 5% molar ratios of the alkali metal to the precursor solution of MAFA.

PL measurements

A homebuilt microscope was used for the PL and time-resolved PL spectroscopy measurements. A picosecond pulse laser with wavelength of 447 nm was used as the excitation, and an objective (40×, numerical aperture = 0.6, Nikon) was used to focus the excitation light on the sample and collect the epic scattered PL emission. A spectrometer and charge-coupled device (CCD) combo (Andor) was used for PL spectral analysis. Time-resolved PL was acquired using a single-photon avalanche diode (PDM series, PicoQuant) and a single-photon counting module (PicoQuant).

TA spectroscopy

TA spectra of the perovskite thin films were measured by a femtosecond pump-probe system with a homebuilt TA spectrometer described in our previous publication (8). Laser pulses at 1030 nm with ~200-fs duration were generated by a 400-kHz amplified Yb:KGW laser system (PHAROS, Light Conversion Ltd.). The probe beam was a white-light continuum beam spanning 450- to 950-nm spectral region, created by focusing 5% of the 1030-nm fundamental output onto a YAG (yttrium aluminum garnet) crystal (4.0 mm thick). The rest of the output pumps an optical parametric amplifier (OPA; TOPAS-Twins, Light Conversion Ltd.) to generate pump pulses at 400 nm (3.1 eV).

TA microscopy

The homebuilt TAM setup used in this study has been described in our previous publication (8). Briefly, the output from two independent OPAs (400 kHz and ~ 200 fs; Light Conversion) served as the pump and probe beam, respectively, which were focused on a sample with an objective (60×, numerical aperture = 0.95, Nikon). An acousto-optic modulator (Gooch and Housego, R23080-1) triggered by a lock-in amplifier (SR830, Stanford Research Systems Inc.) was used to modulate the pump beam. A mechanical translation stage (Thorlabs, DDS600-E) was used to delay the probe with respect to the pump. A 2D galvo mirror (Thorlabs GVS012) was used to scan the probe beam relative to the pump beam in space (path 1 in fig. S8). Spatial filters were used to optimize the profile of the pump and probe beams. The transmitted probe light was detected by an avalanche photodiode (Hamamatsu, C5331-04). The pump-induced change in the probe reflection (ΔT) was extracted by the lock-in amplifier.

Time-dependent density functional theory calculations

The ab initio NA MD simulations were performed using the PYXAID code (37) within the framework of the real-time time-dependent density functional theory (DFT) in the Kohn-Sham representation (36).


Supplementary material for this article is available at

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial license, which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, so long as the resultant use is not for commercial advantage and provided the original work is properly cited.


Acknowledgments: Funding: The work at Purdue (T.W., L.J., J.M.S., S.D., T.Z., and. L.H.) is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences through award DE-SC0016356. W.C. and O.P. acknowledge support of the U.S. National Science Foundation, grant no. CHE-1900510. Author contributions: L.H. and T.W. designed the experiments. T.W., L.J., J.M.S., S.D., and T.Z. carried out the optical measurements. T.W., L.J., and L.H. analyzed the optical measurements. J.H., J.-P.C.-B., and B.L. contributed to sample growth and performed x-ray structural characterizations. W.C. and O.P. carried out and analyzed the DFT calculations. T.W. and L.H. wrote the manuscript with input from all authors. Competing interests: The authors declare that they have no competing interests. Data and materials availability: All data needed to evaluate the conclusions in the paper are present in the paper and/or the Supplementary Materials. Additional data related to this paper may be requested from the authors.
View Abstract

Stay Connected to Science Advances

Navigate This Article